Fork weird dropout design safe to ride?

Hi there,

I recently bought a new bike and the dropout at the end of the fork seemed a bit odd to me when building up the bike (it is a road disc brake bike, carbon fork, using SRAM 's Maxle). Upon further inspection, I found the issue was, that the machined area to receive the front was far bigger (~25mm) than the outer diameter of the end cap (specified at 18,7mm to my knowledge). I did quite a lot of research and found a specified cutout diameter of 19,5mm on an Enve fork drawing.

(Note: after questioning the design and myself for the whole weekend,.I also submitted the question to the geek warning podcast). As I have heard back from the bike brand support team today, that this is the intended design, I have the following questions

  1. Is it just me or is this a uncommon design? Has anyone seen such a fork cutout diameter before?
  2. Why choose such a large diameter?
  3. Will this put additional load on especially the front throughaxle and the front hub?
  4. Would you see this as a robust design and in the end safe to ride?

The last two are with an end cap, as this is quite hard to Fotograph with the wheel inserted.

This is quite normal, there is some variation in end cap diameter so the fork needs to accomodate. Once the thru axle is tight, it doesn’t matter. The load is not taken by the lip of the dropout, as it would be in a quick release wheel.

4 Likes

Agree that it’s not unsafe. The load isn’t meant to be carried from the end cap to the lip on the fork.

But it’s going to make installing the wheel tedious. The lip on the fork is meant to approximately position the wheel so the through axle slides straight from the fork to the wheel.

It almost seems like it was designed for Rock Shox torque caps which are oversized to increase stiffness. But that’s generally a mtb thing and I’ve never come across them on a road or gravel bike.

3 Likes

Thank you for both your feedback. At least I’m relieved this should not put additional stress on the components (as I was not sure whether the tighter fit on the fork would be able to bear for example additional torsional loads during cornering). Mounting the wheel is on fact quite fiddly, but as long as this is the only drawback I can live with it (although this is still annoying with a new bike, as I did not just source some random components from China, but bought this directly from a reputable brand).

On the axle drawing, a Ø23mm MIN Flat Surface is specified on the outside for Thru Axle Head Clearance, so maybe this was wrongly applied on the inside.

The Rock Shox torque cap has 31mm, so the adaptor kit for the hub won’t unfortunately be a bit to large in diameter.

Strictly speaking, the part of the QR dropout that catches the spindle does not take the load if done up correctly. QR and thru axle are actually the same in that once properly tight, friction between the end cap (or locknut) and the side of the dropout lock the two together. With QR, the part of the dropout that catches the spindle is there partly for redundancy but mainly to help align everything, which would be same for any inner lip on thru axle dropout.

so, in the case of the Markus’s fork, no issue once tight, but could be annoying when trying to get the wheel in and aligned to get the thru axle aligned and pushed through into the hole and catching the threads correctly.

2 Likes