I’m listening to the current Geek Warning episode about the dearth of bike mechanics, and largely agree with the analysis that shop mechanic work is getting more difficult, and harder to make money on:
- Proliferation of incompatible designs (it’s not fair to say “standards” until they’re widely accepted) isn’t new, but my sense is it’s becoming more widespread.
- Increased precision requires better quality control and adjustment to work well (e.g., shifting across a 13-speed cassette vs an 8-speed cassette)
- More frames & part designs have serviceability as an afterthought
- Dramatically more variation across manufacturers and parts suppliers means that shops can’t stock as high a % of what customers will need
Dave and Ronan ask that manufacturers stop coming out with new “standards” and designs, which will make life easier on shops and consumers. And it would.
But from what I understand, consumers are the main reason that manufacturers keep spinning out new incompatible designs. As is often discussed, bikes are durable, and the bike industry relies on repeated sales to the same enthusiasts, buying new bikes before their old bikes are worn out. And as I understand it, new “standards” and designs, whether or not they are meaningfully better, are part of the hook to get people to buy newer/improved-er bikes. Which is to say, MANUFACTURERS DO THIS BECAUSE CONSUMER BEHAVIOR REWARDS IT.
My road bikes are late-1970s/early-1980s frames that were designed around 27" (630mm BSD) wheels, which can comfortably run 700c*35mm or even 38mm slicks, and I spread the rear triangles to 130mm. Sure, threaded headsets and especially horizontal dropouts are worse, but not by that much. My gravel bike is a canti-brake Soma Double Cross whose stays have been crimped to increase tire clearance. I’m plenty familiar with current standards (and not all of my bikes are oldish) and from time to time I’ll post a “how much am I giving up by using older stuff” thread.
There are plenty of people like me, whether for frugality, anti-consumerism or other reasons, but the bike industry doesn’t make much money off us, and so reasonably focuses on the people who are likely to spend for a new-and-improved thing.
All to say - I think it’s more fair to view consumers as the reason (or fault, if you prefer) for the proliferation of stuff that shops need to handle.
Am I overstating consumers as the cause here?
I see three potential avenues for improving the situation:
-
consumers penalize (i.e., generally avoid) new “standards” that haven’t met a fairly high bar of how will this improve my performance?
-
most consumers place higher value on ease of serviceability and ability to buy replacement parts. However, I’m not hopeful this happens at scale; it’s akin to local voters rewarding politicians who focus on maintenance of assets rather than building new things. And the typical trend of what voters reward is very much not in this direction.
-
riders with less incentive to maximize performance place a lower value on maximizing performance.
I’m not particularly hopeful about any of these happening at scale, but there’s room for some culture to develop around these.
