Bike industry makes things worse on shops - because consumers reward it

I’m listening to the current Geek Warning episode about the dearth of bike mechanics, and largely agree with the analysis that shop mechanic work is getting more difficult, and harder to make money on:

  • Proliferation of incompatible designs (it’s not fair to say “standards” until they’re widely accepted) isn’t new, but my sense is it’s becoming more widespread.
  • Increased precision requires better quality control and adjustment to work well (e.g., shifting across a 13-speed cassette vs an 8-speed cassette)
  • More frames & part designs have serviceability as an afterthought
  • Dramatically more variation across manufacturers and parts suppliers means that shops can’t stock as high a % of what customers will need

Dave and Ronan ask that manufacturers stop coming out with new “standards” and designs, which will make life easier on shops and consumers. And it would.

But from what I understand, consumers are the main reason that manufacturers keep spinning out new incompatible designs. As is often discussed, bikes are durable, and the bike industry relies on repeated sales to the same enthusiasts, buying new bikes before their old bikes are worn out. And as I understand it, new “standards” and designs, whether or not they are meaningfully better, are part of the hook to get people to buy newer/improved-er bikes. Which is to say, MANUFACTURERS DO THIS BECAUSE CONSUMER BEHAVIOR REWARDS IT.

My road bikes are late-1970s/early-1980s frames that were designed around 27" (630mm BSD) wheels, which can comfortably run 700c*35mm or even 38mm slicks, and I spread the rear triangles to 130mm. Sure, threaded headsets and especially horizontal dropouts are worse, but not by that much. My gravel bike is a canti-brake Soma Double Cross whose stays have been crimped to increase tire clearance. I’m plenty familiar with current standards (and not all of my bikes are oldish) and from time to time I’ll post a “how much am I giving up by using older stuff” thread.

There are plenty of people like me, whether for frugality, anti-consumerism or other reasons, but the bike industry doesn’t make much money off us, and so reasonably focuses on the people who are likely to spend for a new-and-improved thing.

All to say - I think it’s more fair to view consumers as the reason (or fault, if you prefer) for the proliferation of stuff that shops need to handle.

Am I overstating consumers as the cause here?

I see three potential avenues for improving the situation:

  1. consumers penalize (i.e., generally avoid) new “standards” that haven’t met a fairly high bar of how will this improve my performance?

  2. most consumers place higher value on ease of serviceability and ability to buy replacement parts. However, I’m not hopeful this happens at scale; it’s akin to local voters rewarding politicians who focus on maintenance of assets rather than building new things. And the typical trend of what voters reward is very much not in this direction.

  3. riders with less incentive to maximize performance place a lower value on maximizing performance.

I’m not particularly hopeful about any of these happening at scale, but there’s room for some culture to develop around these.

18 Likes

Individualism and consumerism were at the very least fueled by parties that wanted to stimulate either economy in general or fill their own pocket. They did so by appealing to basic human desires in a more intense and frequent manner than ever before. That was possible via commercial mass media. And recently turned to 11 via social media.

Given were we are now, the loss of social control, and the level of self-reflection by most people, I’m afraid I must consider it a nice dream that things will change by itself.

2 Likes

While consumers certainly share some of the responsibility for what’s going on with bike shops and what’s going on with the bike industry, I don’t think any single party can be singled out as the single party responsible or even the party most responsible. Manufacturers, bike media, shops, and consumers have all contributed to the state of things now, and that means any real solution is going require change on the part of all parties.

5 Likes

I am not sure if any 70s or 80s tech has relevance for the discussion 50 (!) years later. Sorry, that is before I was born. Also, in my experience modern road bike tech has become easier to service. Electric shifting is ridiculously easy to set up, the same goes for hydraulic disc brakes. No fiddling with cables, no cables breaking in difficult to reach spots, adjustable with the pressing on a few buttons. I am an amateur mechanic, and I have no problem building a bike from scratch in an afternoon, with cables through the handlebars and all, using the tools in my small toolkit. I think disc brakes, electric shifting, thruaxles make bikes better. Integrated cables have advantages that outweigh the disadvantages for me. And if I as an amateur mechanic can deal with it, I think that most pro mechanics should not have an issue with it. I would not have tools to service your 50 year old tech at home though, and my only rim brake bike (33 year old Santana tandem) regularly need service from a bike shop, because it has some standards I have a hard time getting the tools for.

6 Likes

I agree with a part of your comment, but I think the last sentence is exactly the issue that’s being discussed. Yes, in my opinion, bikes are getting less mechanically complex to keep operable - electronic drivetrains are easier to maintain and set up, hydraulic disc brake systems can be more set and forget with minimal bleed/pad servicing, etc. - but most of these hardware changes, while allowing for the “operability” band to be broader, increase complexity of overhaul service (the only support that 99% shops can offer on an AXS RD with a stuck pin is a warranty claim, at best) and reduce the absolute lifespan of componentry either functionally (earlier gen Di2 electronics are not decade-lasting equipment choices) or economically (what if ya’ need headset spacers for your Gen 5 Madone?).

As an individual consumer and rider, getting the tools and know-how to do entry to mid-level mechanical maintenance on the bikes you own is easier than ever - I agree with you; but that is not why people go to bike shops, and that is not what shops need to supply to folks and be prepared to offer. As you state, more and more, people go to bike shops for the edge cases - to supply the tools and know-how that they don’t have the time or money to invest in because they need it once every four years. Those instances are not profitable for bike shop service departments. Traditionally, the time-sinks, the $400 headset bearing press, the draw cabinent with 68 different derailleur hangers are subsidized by the higher margin, formulaic tune-ups and parts sales that are being reduced by the industry choices. Because the larger bike assembly is becoming more set-and-forget, and less routinely servicable (from a blind ride perspective), that equation for service departments is breaking down - that’s the subject of the podcast for discussion and @DrTallRider 's point.

6 Likes

First ever post here; hello Escape folx!

I replied to a similar post on Instragram from Cycling Weekly. I’d like to share my take on this below as part of the above conversation.

Employers / shop owners need to value their staff and pay good wages that are commensurate with the high skill job that being a top end mechanic is and always has been whilst recognising that without skilled, professional mechanics their business is nothing (unless the owner is also a skilled operator).

Why do we have a lack of mechanic’s? Because the industry has too long suffered from what I call ‘Saturday Boy Syndrome’: the idea that wrenching for a living is a low skilled, lifestyle choice and that we should be glad for the peanuts that employers throw us whilst they reap the financial rewards. Myself and **every** other professional mechanic that I’d TRUST have all moved out of working for others and now run our own ships supporting ourselves and those around us. Others have become self employed plumbers, electricians etc. Meanwhile hobbyists in sheds start thinking that they can start their own repair business only to find that ‘it’s just bikes’ does not ring true if you want to operate at a high level (with the caveat being those that take it seriously and professionally can likely do well).

Customers need to understand or be educated that quality work costs real money: ‘it’s just bikes’ falls down in the face of the reality of modern, high end, cycling and the skill set required to work on a broad range of machines whilst keeping up with an ever evolving landscape of standards and technology.

Bottom line; bike industry bigwigs and owners caved into capitalism rather than community; their failure to value the people that allowed the industry to thrive and be self sufficient has led to the current skills gap / lack across the industry. We are doomed to repeat this pattern if we don’t learn from past mistakes.

There’s more to the conversation of course, and I made several more replies on the insta post; I dig that people here are bringing up consumer and capitalism.

11 Likes

I am still not sure that the solution is going back to standards from the 70s? The same for the drawer with 68 different derailleur hangers. It seems the industry is converging on UDH. And I don’t think that subsidising one kind of service with another is a good or sustainable business model. Good service is worth the money, and at least around here, the stores that offer good service, and regularly update their knowledge, have less issues staying in business than those who are stuck in their thinking in the past (and still think rim brakes are coming back, and refuse to learn how to properly bleed disc brakes).

2 Likes

9 Likes

I don’t think anyone is advocating for that, especially on an industry/technical podcast like Geek Warning. Whenever I hear older mechanics or industry professionals that have had experience with that era (I’m in the same ballpark age cohort as you - i.e. my industry experience does not include anything before ~2019), it’s brought up as a paradigmatic reference, not an explicitly innumerated goal. If there was an accessible alternate reality where all current-gen electronic parts were fully modular and servicable and you could disassemble and rebuild a lower-tier hydro caliper in 20 mins., mechanics would use that as a reference vs. the 70s and 80s where that level of interaction with componentry was the norm. I took the discussion on Geek Warning as an industry-to-industry take, and the interaction as an individual consumer (either shared in the podcast or just this forum discussion) as auxiliary and responsive to that, not the other way around. I think that directionality is wholly what makes this point relevant.

As an example, sure, my grandpa grumbles that “cars these days aren’t servicable anymore. You could do anything on my '68 Stang with a socket set and a six-pack!”. That isn’t the same as a service garage manager sharing the take that current engineering trends that are manifesting in very specific technical componentry integration that impacts their workflows prohibitively, and, from a mechanic’s perspective with a large degree of multi-faceted nuance, detrimental to the industry, despite surficial similarity.

As a last point, there are just aspects of any service industry that are not profitable. Of course they should be minimized, but that factually necessitates a reduction in provided service options, which in turn makes the infrequent customer base harder to maintain. In contrast, though, to the auto industry in the US at least, where driving is an unavoidable necessity of modern life, cycling is largely an industry motivated by hobby and passion, not need. This can require that appealling to the widest possible customer base is sometimes to only way to acheive a sustainable customer throughput - acting as an opposing incentive to a decrease in service range and creating a very tough, always changing calculation. That’s what makes my point of service subsidies relevant - the ability to provide any new service requires an investment, but the increased propriety of design and the engineering choices that reduce customer return, at their current pace, is changing the economics of those choices on a scale that is mismatched with the return timeline. @DrTallRider 's point is that many of the factors that are resulting in the OE manufacturer-imposed economic stresses on service departments are partially driven by end-user preference.

4 Likes

I worked more or less full-time in a shop in the 80’s. I’m well familiar with the “standards” and issues of that time. First off, anyone who cherishes the tech of the 80’s has rocks in their head! :slight_smile: I’m being purposely harsh, some stuff was better but nobody in their right mind wants to go back to friction shifters and square tapers. And there weren’t really any better standards. We had a box of BB axles for the 100 different combos of BB bearing distances and chainline distances. I don’t look back on those things with fondness really as a mechanic.

Having said that, the industry does encourage new trends to keep up sales. Some of those trends are good, some..well… My observations from the last 5 years:

  • manufacturers are struggling, there are a lot of them out there, with a lot of models, and dealers are collateral damage. Some of those MFGs are already going away. A few former shop owners have told me they’re buying bikes at booking time (traditionally the cheapest and best time to buy) only to have the manufacturer selling direct to consumer at or below that cost. Not always, but that’s happening. And dealer agreements prevent you from selling bikes below the price the manufacturer sets. You can’t just drop the price to your cost because you have 100 bikes, you have to set the price according to the manufacturer or you lose your ability to sell their product. And by buying in the fall for the following season you’re assuming a great risk. Many people don’t understand the that SHOP owns the bikes..not the manufacturer. So you have to guess how many bikes you’ll need and then hope you can sell them, because you can’t eat them and you can’t discount them without manufacturer approval. Another example is MFGs having BOGO sales and expecting dealers to pay for the assembly of the second bike, and that bike has to come from the MFG, not the dealer’s inventory. I get it, the MFG is in an existential state..but how far can a shop go?
  • bikes have always been second drawer for people. The part supply system, compared to automobiles, is very second rate. And people don’t want to pay for these things. If you have a 1975 AMC Gremlin you can probably find OEM parts somewhere, for almost anything. Try finding a seal kit for a 7 year old hydraulic brake caliper for a bike. And actually GETTING the parts is not easy. MFG’s are not really in the business of servicing all parts for all their bikes for 25 years. So you end up going through distributors or dealers. But if the MFGs are actively killing the dealers and distributors… This probably won’t get better with so many MFGs and parts makers.
  • the idea that shops can pay top drawer money for mechanics is…tough. Margins are low, it’s often seasonal work, shops are barely scraping by. People already balk at prices. I wanted to be a full-time tech, but the money just wasn’t there. I ended up in engineering and only now, at retirement, can contemplate doing bike stuff because I love doing it and don’t need to make a living at it. And the fact there are less mechs out there is great for me, I’ll probably have steady work to keep me busy. But even I find it daunting that.. (see below)
  • there is a lot of non-standardization and need for special tools. This is also true in cars, but with cars you are paid well, have steady work and know you will be working on that 2024 Subaru hub bearing over and over and the investment in the bearing puller is worth the money. And people know they have to pay for their car parts. And they will pay. A car tire is $150…some bike tires are $150…car tires last 3 years..you see how the pricing is prohibitive for average people. Ever wonder why we need 17 different sealed bearings for bicycle wheels? It’s certainly not a technical requirement… It’s actively sabotaging the industry because of the first few points. It’s a perfect storm of self-destruction.

I had a friend in the motorcycle business, and he opened a new shop. I said, are you going to sell new motorcycles? He said, not if I can help it. See above. This was 20 years ago. Already he could see the clouds brewing. There is a LOT of financial risk selling new bicycles. And to have the MFGs actively fighting you for profit, I don’t see why many normal people would want to get into that business. Yeah, if you love it and are prepared for financial pain forever when you could be making a lot of money in some other business that takes up less time and is less frustrating, great. But I think many folks are just saying, I don’t need this anymore, I’m going to do something else. Anything that you love to do that becomes a painful full-time job will kill your love of that thing eventually.

8 Likes

I think there’s something of a yin and yang relationship here that perhaps gets overlooked.

Consumerism might be what incentivises manufacturers to keep producing new products, but it’s also what incentivises them to innovate in the first place. Without consumers willing to pay for something new or better, where’s the commercial incentive to invest in technological progress?

Technological progress almost inevitably comes at the expense of older technology. In a capitalist economy, manufacturers need to generate a return on their investment, and that generally means focusing their resources on products for which there’s sufficient demand.

Perhaps the answer isn’t to favour one extreme over the other, but to recognise that there’s a balance to be struck. We don’t want to preserve every old standard at the expense of progress, any more than we want progress at the expense of all backwards compatibility and serviceability.

And to a considerable extent, isn’t that balance already there? You can still buy square-taper bottom brackets, rim brakes and all manner of older components. They may be less readily available because fewer people want them, and therefore fewer manufacturers have an incentive to produce them, but they haven’t disappeared.

Of course, there’s a legitimate argument against introducing incompatibility purely for its own sake, particularly where there’s no meaningful benefit. But that’s rather different from suggesting that the industry’s constant pursuit of new products is fundamentally a problem.

Ultimately, consumers want what they want, and manufacturers respond because their businesses depend on doing so. That’s hardly unique to cycling; it’s the basic economic mechanism that drives innovation across countless industries.

Perhaps the question shouldn’t be how we stop this process, but how we strike a sensible balance between innovation, compatibility and consumer choice.

4 Likes

Lots of great comments but (as a former long term bike biz member) Scott_Anderson pretty well sums it up. As for older bikes vs new maintenance-wise, I’ll take discs brakes any day. Man, the time invested in replacing pads and adjusting the brakes. Which was made worse by cantilevers, u-brakes, v-brakes, and the wide assortment of finicky CNC’d “cool” brakes that had to be jussssst right to work. And then there’s chains. Using a chain-breaker to remove and install was a PITA.

Did the changes happen because consumers rewarded it? Maybe. Is that different from any other product? No.

The really issue for shops is the one word Scott_Anderson dropped: Margins. Shops never made much money and many were and are now one disaster from closing. There is also the consumer having. zero clue about margins. If I had a buck for every time I was selling a bike and a customer tried to haggle the prices as they would buying a car. That has not changed at all. This Summer I was at a shop and overheard the same BS, except the customer brought up the price of a DTC brand. The shop owner was diplomatic with how he said nope. After the customer left I asked if that was a common thing these days. He ruefully said yes, every day.

Going back in time would not fix a darn thing, to be frank. Going forward we’ll have fewer brands after the glut sorts itself out. And I predict we’ll have fewer shops with higher costs for repair. Sure, if it works for you penalize new designs, pretend that parts will always be available, and don’t give a hoot about performance. Let’s see how that works to save the LBS.

I’ll not be holding my breath.

5 Likes

Interesting discussion. So much of what has been said are good observations of the industry and retailers in particular…many overlapping causes of the current situation. One major reason why I haven’t been to a shop for service in 20 years is because I had so many bad experiences, even back then. And now I see my cycling buddies getting similar treatment by the shops they bring their bikes to. They wait days or even a couple of weeks to get their bikes back for very minor repairs or maintenance (and not because the shop is waiting on parts). When they do get their bike back quite often the original problem persists. For example, one guy had a brake issue. I checked it out and it seemed to be there was some air in the line. As he had not had it serviced in 2-3 years I recommended bleeding the brakes and changing the pads. After five days the shop changed only the rear pads and gave him back the bike, saying it was fixed. Of course it was not any better and I myself changed the front pads and bled the system for him. Another guy had rear shifting issues. The shop had his bike for a week and “adjusted it”. It was the same when he got it back. Turns out the chain was incredibly stretched out and had worn the rear cassette such that a new chain and a new cassette was required. These are just two examples. At least in my area, there do not seem to be many “pro” mechanics. The main cause of that? Perhaps a general lack of appreciation of the craft and few pathways for younger people to get into that kind of job… but mostly because it just doesn’t pay well I would imagine.

5 Likes

Some of those frames are before I was born, too.

I wasn’t recommending late-70s/early-80s tech as a better alternative (most of my road frames are from that era, not the parts). The reason I mentioned my using a fair bit of older stuff is to note that the bike industry doesn’t make much money on riders who mostly ride stuff that’s good-enough that they already have.

Yeah, I wasn’t bringing up that era of frames as a general recommendation. And my road bikes build around older frames use very few parts from that era.

To your point about complexity at the time, I think it’s easy to look back on a prior era and think that the standards were well-worked-out, but that’s mainly because we’re mostly aware of the common approaches that won and stuck around. Even the threaded headset ISO and JIS standards weren’t always consistent, and of course there were tons of BB threadings in generally-similar-looking shells, although BSA won out and is still commonly used.

But my sense is that didn’t contribute to as much overhead-cost-of-what-to-stock problem for bike shops, as there is today. SRAM winning with the UDH is a great case of simplification, but that doesn’t seem to be the general trend.

The proliferation of different incompatible designs leads me down an interesting path. Whilst across the household we have bought many bikes, particularly in the 11sp days there was also an element of ‘Ship of Theseus’, and we probably spent more incrementally upgrading one bike piecemeal, until we’d have two. We’d often use local bike shops for the components and the wrenching, because taken bit by bit it doesn’t feel too expensive.

More recently, the massive explosion of quasi bespoke designs means that this option is less possible, and pushes towards a whole new bike rather than incremental upgrading. The large lump sum of that makes me more reluctant to do so, and the net effect is likely less spent.

Not to say there shouldn’t be progress, but a narrower set of interface options may overall draw more money from me.

1 Like

Giving this subject further thought, I think it’s worth noting that even if manufacturers desire having their products be cross-brand compatible they may be prevented from doing so due to patents. In other words, it can be way less expensive to design a new standard vs paying legal fees.

2 Likes

I think this is wrong. Increasing specialization, unique tools, proprietary parts should all generally benefit professional service shops.

I think what makes things harder for shops is that parts have gotten so damn good and reliable. It used to be that mechanical derailleurs always needed adjusting, spokes were always breaking and cup and cone bearings needed service.

Shops could charge $10 for an adjustment that took 30 seconds.

Now electronic derailleurs never need adjusting, spokes don’t break, and $200 bearings last forever. That means most of the jobs that are left to shops are the really crappy ones.

The bike industry is making it harder on service shops by making bikes that are better and need less service. Do we really want companies to bring back crappy rims and spokes so that bike shops can replace them more often?

2 Likes

My problem with bike shops is getting my bike to the shop.

I would pay top dollar for a subscription-like service where a mechanic knew my bike, came to my home, serviced it regularly , ordered the parts it needed, etc. I imagine I’m not alone. With this business model mechanics could benefit from regular, predictable cash flows. Give customers their time back and you can charge the premium mechanics deserve.

5 Likes

I wonder if we’ll start to see SaaS-like shop fees for priority access to scheduling and order-ahead special parts. “Concierge medicine” in healthcare. Something has got to give if margins are that bad.

I don’t think it’s all bad, for instance, as some mentioned it’s great that derailleurs and brakes don’t need much servicing - my first road bike had mechanical disc brakes and I don’t think I would have continued cycling much longer if I hadn’t changed my setup.

Some of the issues create opportunities, if I ran a shop, I’d work out a great experience for integrated cockpits:

  1. Sourcing - I’d work out the right models that can support a good fit, there are so many options from length, width, angle, routing etc.
  2. 3D printing to make the cockpit and frame fit - once you have the tools and knowledge for that, you can replace a bunch of small proprietary pieces too.
  3. Add couplers - Dave’s article and comments showed how tricky it can be to put them in the right place.

Combine this with the subscription service that @Matthew_Bart recommended where they figure out delivery in an efficient way - right now I’d pay almost 50% more to get the bike picked up for the service.

2 Likes